Wiki for Dr. McClurkens Courses

You've loaded an old revision of the document! If you save it, you will create a new version with this data.

====== Nye, 29-132, 138-142, 182-184, 287-291, 304-307, 314-317, 322-338 ======

==== Chapter 2, Great White Way ====
Kaden - A chapter regarding rising American presence in industry and the developments therein with a focus on the introduction of electricity, a gamechanger for many aspects of production.

This chapter focuses on the introduction of electricity to major cities around the world, and the social and cultural impacts of the idea of electrification. One thing of note that I thought was interesting in this chapter was that literature of the time often emphasizes lighting as "white" along side other grandiose adjectives. I wonder if this emphasis relates to the embedding of electrification into Darwinist ideologies of racial superiority? - CJ Nemetz

The chapter provides a detailed analysis of the development of electricity in theaters, advertisements, public utilities, and other domains. In addition, the author links the history of electricity to broader cultural discourses, such as the ideas of progress and civilization in contrast to barbarism and the darkness of jungles. In my view, one of the most interesting aspects of the chapter is its discussion of the aesthetic category of the sublime, as electricity introduced a new dimension to the technological sublime. In classical theory, as formulated by Edmund Burke, the sublime strikes the imagination through a sudden feeling of horror in the face of ungraspable vastness. I wonder whether after electricity, railroads, etc.. - nuclear weapons, as symbols of utter destruction, might be seen as a logical culmination of modern examples of the technological sublime. - Nikolai Kotkov

This chapter talks about how electricity affected people, particularly in urban places. electricity and the rise of it became a symbol for modernity and progress and a source of pride. However, it was also connected with racism and classism, as only rich white people in rich white areas would have access to electricity. - Oliver M

Electric lighting transformed city streets into places of wonder and excitement. People were drawn to the brightness not only for safety but also for the sense of modern progress it represented. The spectacle of light became a cultural symbol of technology shaping everyday life.-- Caitlyn Edwards.

This chapter has talked about the big impact and growth of Thomas Edison's lightbulb and electric system on the world that had used fire and gas to light the nights.  Probably one of the big examples I've seen is how the famous Paris exhibition in the past attempted to stay open later at night, but there were problems using gas lights.  However, in 1881, the introduction of lightbulbs and electric system had a completely different impact that made it successful at night.  Not only was Edison's company selling lightbulbs, it also sold the means to produce power to other companies so that they can then used them to stay open later.  - David Y.

I got from this chapter, the marketing, and social aspects of technology in cities. The chapter talked about how brighter lights, that could be seen from further distances attracted people to them more. Especially when adding in the designs of signs and buildings with different colored lights. The chapter also put an importance on cities to compete with one another with how grand their system of lights, specifically in the fairs and exhibitions. Again, trying to attract people to their city. -James Clayberg

This chapter goes into great detail about the impact of electricity on city life. One way like in Broadway in New York was shown has symbolism and progress from the bright electrical lights. It also gave them an urban identity showing that they were progressing and growing. - Will C

One thing I found interesting from this chapter was the marketing tactics of the electric system. Prior to reading this chapter, this wasn’t exactly a form of technology that I thought would need marketing. But as it is pointed out in the chapter, light attracts public congregation which allows for the growth of businesses and foot traffic. - Ava B

This chapter goes into extensive detail about the introduction and impact of electricity on life in the city. In some ways, the adoption of electricity (electric lighting specifically) in the cities served as it's own form of marketing and advertising. If the city, with its lights and factories and progress were the future, then theoretically adopting some of their technologies (like lights) would get you closer to that. Broadway, and other similarly lit up spectacles served exactly that purpose in some ways. - Abby F.

I thought the portion of them talking about the theatrical lighting was really interesting. They were willing to spend a bunch of money for special lighting as it brought box office success. It’s impressive how “special effects" started off, such as L.J. Duboscq designing rainbows, and “luminous fountain” for performances and spaces such as the Paris Opera House. This also included the use of arc lamps. - Izzy Ellenberger

Nye reminds us that electricity did not first enter American life through the home or the factory, but through public display and shared spectacle. Before wires ran into kitchens and workshops, Americans encountered electricity as a kind of wonder at world’s fairs, city streetlight displays, and the great illuminations of Niagara Falls. These moments mattered because they gave the new technology its earliest meanings. People did not simply see electricity as a neutral force; they were taught to view it as a symbol of progress, modernity, and even national destiny. Nye shows how these collective experiences shaped public imagination long before electricity became an everyday utility. In this way, electricity arrived as more than wires and bulbs, it was a cultural promise, framed as a path forward for America itself. - Todd Holman

==== Chapter 3, Crosstown Transfer ====

Kaden - This chapter explores the introduction of streetcars, a product of electrical redesigns in industry.

Contrary to the previous chapter, the introduction of streetcars into early 20th century was tumultuous. Regardless, streetcars acted in a similar vain as the introduction of electricity to cities as the advent of advertising pervading all aspects of life. - CJ Nemetz

This chapter focuses on the development of streetcars, as well as the institutions that expanded in their wake. Particular attention is given to the ways in which streetcars, amusement parks, public transportation systems, gas stations, and other car-related utilities transformed American society from a Victorian modus vivendi to a mass-consumer society. - Nikolai Kotkov

The evolution from old to new, modern technology using electricity, including the street car, which had similar socio-political effects that electricity in general had. However, it was a more public use of electricity that was more positive than just rich people having it in their houses. -- Oliver M

This chapter looked at how streetcars not only led to the expansion of the radius a person could travel. But also the dangers or lack of safety of travel. Streetcars connected people to other places in the city and even outside cities. It touched on the impacts of this by increasing or decreasing property values. And the beginning of loss to regional identities now that longer distance every-day travel existed. Streetcars also created more tension between unions and the employers. I noted from this chapter that it mentioned streetcars were selected over underground trains, I wonder with the development of cars, if that's the reason metro trains become selected over streetcars. - James Clayberg

The chapter focuses on the development of streetcars which made it faster, cheaper and cleaner to travel through the city. This increased mobility within cities a lot making life easier and more accessible to people. - Will C

What we saw in this chapter was the cycle of what happened when technology met a problem and phased out old tech while meeting new challenges.  As cities grew, the need for better transportation came up.  With the street car, they allowed further travel from city centers, which phases out horse carts as the main transport method (and all the required services to keep them running).  This also required new services to keep these street cars running smoothly as well as new rules and challenges to them.  This also shows how people who see something that could be a big money maker attracted these businessmen to acquire these riches. - David Y.

Chapter 3 primarily focused on the creation and impact of electric streetcars on everyday city life. Similarly to the effects of lighting, streetcars opened the doors to new ways and places to advertise. They also opened up new jobs within the city itself, such as maintenance crews and other streetcar staff. Streetcars also bridged gaps within the city itself, allowing for speedier, cheaper travel between regions, eventually decreasing some intercity cultural differences and opening up jobs for more of a cities population. People who lived on opposite sides of the city from potential jobs now had a more consistent, cheaper, faster, method of commute. - Abby

The street car completely reshaped the social landscape of the American lifestyle. It opened the door for suburban expansion while simultaneously facilitating class segregation. Street cars linked urban and rural areas, offering Americans the opportunity to escape and embrace the cityscape. It’s an interesting mix of connecting and fragmenting the population. - Izabella Martinez

I liked how in this reading and the other it talks about the use of art and demonstrating the urban changed in something such as a painting. It showcases progress  and shows and new prospective on the world. This chapter covered the growth of the electric transportation such as the trolley, car, train, etc. and how people started to become heavily reliant on them. It also covered safety and political concerns. - Izzy Ellenberger

==== Chapter 4, What was Electricity? 138-142, 182-184 ====

Kaden - Now-outdated designs were once the best when it came to electricity. This chapter made me think of the American transfer to bessemer steel and how, once inaccessible due to cost, technology has risen to meet the need for better things. The profit incentive, a large driver, made for a roundabout way of forcing ingenuity.

These passages examine different interpretations of electricity among various interest groups, including businessmen (electricity as a commodity), government officials (electricity as a utility and a political weapon), and artists and intellectuals (electricity as a natural god, a manifestation of the technological sublime, and a sign of civilization). - Nikolai Kotkov

I found it interesting how the electrification of Europe was mostly state controlled. They built it up more for the social welfare aspect of it rather than profit. Compared to America where this was the opposite and was built primarily with the wealthy in mind. It reminds me of the healthcare debate that’s been going on for a very long time now, profits versus welfare. - Justin Hoskins

Electricity was interpreted in many different ways, as the variety of sustenance means in the American ecosystem subjugated people to understand it and use it in different ways. These differences caused tension at political and economic levels, and at the philosophical level as electricity became more prevalent. - CJ Nemetz

As happens with anything new and important under capitalism :(, electricity quickly became a socio-political issue. Companies, governments, unions/workers, and the masses all had different ideas of how electricity could be used, marketed, sold, bought, etc and they all were just trying to get the most out of it economically. A true classic story as told frequently in this class. -- Oliver M.

The chapter really just explained the multifaceted uses and power deferent people had for certain aspects of electricity. Thus, spawning different class systems. Electricity also has an importance to government policies and again, different groups of people benefited and other didn't, especially as we get closer and look at the reasons for the coming depression. --James Clayberg

Electricity is more than just a technological system, and has influence over economics and ideologies. I find it really interesting though what it meant for different communities. For the government it meant an area of regulation, for companies a marketable product, and others a simple improvement on everyday life. All roads lead to capitalism doesn’t it. :( - Ava B

The stories we tell in this class pretty much always come to capitalism at one point or another, here is where the story of electricity does so. Electricity meant a lot of things to a lot of very different people, in many cases it meant conflicting things too. For members of the government, many of whom were wealthy as it was, electricity was something to be regulated and controlled on the side of the government, in personal lives, it was something to be invested in. A surefire way to make a buck or two. For those lower down on the economic ladder, it meant longer work hours, but also cities that were more easily navigable, more (and/or different) jobs, and, if you could afford it, housekeeping work may become just a tiny bit easier. Chances were you couldn't afford it though. - Abby F

As Electricity was starting to grow and expand, it was only natural that its influence be shaped by those who would take advantage of it.  Private companies sought to control it as well as the means in which to produce electricity, just as they had in the past. - David Y.

This chapter focused on the electrification of America and the business aspect that came into play with private funding. Electricity was developed more as an opportunity to control profit than a service provided for the people. - Izabella Martinez

It mentions electricity to be incorporated in many things, listed as a spectacle,  means of transportation, source of profit, etc. It also classified in a cultural/symbolic entity as the use of electricity differed based off of ones class in society. - Izzy Ellenberger

==== Chapter 7, Rural Lines -- 287-291, 304-307, 314-317, 322-338 ====
Kaden - As workers leave the farms and go to the factories, rural hardships arise as a lacking labor force must make for the deficit. Women gained more independence as a result, forced into traditionally male jobs to help.

These chapters trace the influence of electricity on agriculture and farming life. One of the most interesting passages, in particular, discusses the transformation of the Jeffersonian agrarian ideal with the advent of electricity. - Nikolai Kotkov

This chapter focuses on the integration of electricity into agricultural life. I found some contrast between this chapter and chapter 4, as it appears in this chapter that progressive era government programs helped blend the separate interpretations of electricity while attempting to help both sides, rather than being a point of conflict. Farmers reaped (no pun intended) the benefits of electricity while the government benefited from the subliminal promotion of new deal ideas that rural electrification harbored. - CJ Nemetez

The key aspect of this chapter was the shift from a balance of farmers and city workers to the drastic change of 1 of 7 workers working in agriculture and then eventually 1 in 33. The less farmers needed showed how agricultural ideology transformed, as well as the economic and political shift these people had. It also touched on the change in a women's role in a farmhouse. --James Clayberg

With the increase of electrical light and factories, it makes sense that the agricultural field is hurt by these changes. While there were benefits to the industrialization of farms such as relief of some household chores and increased productivity, I can’t help but think that overall electricity increased expectations of agricultural and household output. - Ava B

Chapter 7 traces the impacts and changes caused by the introduction of electricity to American farm life. It touched on the drastic decrease in the number of farmers in the country, as well as the changing role of women in the farm house and on the farm itself. Decreasing rural work forces create spaces in agricultural America for the introduction of electricity. It also put more intense demand on what was left of the rural workforce, which only continued to decrease. - Abby F

It was quite interesting to learn that unlike America, Europe had focused its electrification of farmer and civilian sectors much sooner than America did.  President Theodore Roosevelt however saw how important the farmers were to America and worked to make sure they got the same benefits from electric power that private companies did. - David Y.

In this reading you can really see how the people in the urban society really took electricity and the access to it for granted as people out in the rural and farmland areas were often bypassed. The people in the rural areas had to continuously try to advocate for electricity. - Izzy Ellenberger

Edit summary

Note: By editing this page you agree to license your content under the following license: CC Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International