Wiki for Dr. McClurkens Courses

User Tools

Site Tools

Trace: • week_2_questions_comments-325_25
week_12_questions_comments-325_25

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
week_12_questions_comments-325_25 [2025/11/13 13:29] – [Nye, 238-286, “A Clean, Well-lighted Hearth”] 76.78.172.133week_12_questions_comments-325_25 [2025/11/14 14:32] (current) – [Document A -- Taylor] 199.111.65.11
Line 15: Line 15:
 This chapter focuses on changes both inside and out of the home as more and more of the US transferred from gas and fire lighting and appliances to electric ones. It discusses how interior design was drastically changed from this switch, since electricity brought about more distinct types of rooms separated by interior walls. I was very interested in the concept of feminist apartment hotels, and I’d love to read more about those! - Noah Rutkowski This chapter focuses on changes both inside and out of the home as more and more of the US transferred from gas and fire lighting and appliances to electric ones. It discusses how interior design was drastically changed from this switch, since electricity brought about more distinct types of rooms separated by interior walls. I was very interested in the concept of feminist apartment hotels, and I’d love to read more about those! - Noah Rutkowski
  
 +In this chapter, new household technologies symbolized modernity and progress in America. While innovations like electric lighting and appliances promised convenience, they also reinforced gender roles and expectations around domestic life, showing how technology shaped both culture and everyday living.---Caitlyn Edwards
 +
 +Nye’s “A Clean, Well-lighted Hearth” captures how electrification reshaped both the structure of the American home and the ideals that governed it. I was especially drawn to his discussion of how “modern” domestic technologies promised liberation but often reinforced traditional gender roles instead. The vision of electricity as progress illuminating, efficient, and civilized masked the reality that domestic labor still fell largely on women, only now redefined as a mark of modern competence. Nye’s analysis reminds us that every new technology carries cultural expectations, not just mechanical innovation. - Todd Holman
 ====== Pursell, 116-143 ====== ====== Pursell, 116-143 ======
  
Line 28: Line 31:
  
 In this section it expresses that the massaging was specifically set for the means of clinical use, or as it was camouflaged to be. Otherwise it would have been societally marked as immoral. – Izzy Ellenberger In this section it expresses that the massaging was specifically set for the means of clinical use, or as it was camouflaged to be. Otherwise it would have been societally marked as immoral. – Izzy Ellenberger
 +
 +This chapter explore the nuanced approach taken to sexual technologies. With any other approach, it may have been considered a taboo. By marking these inventions as possessing medical benefits and clinical backing, consumers feel less immoral by engaging with the product. - Kaden Crim
  
 I am actually in a Perspectives in Sexuality class this semester so this chapter was especially interesting for me to read, and I’d like to add some supplemental information I learned in that class here (I brought this reading up in that class for discussion, too). One of my readings for that class this week was about the evolution of feminist sex shops that first came about in the 1970s, which is quite relevant to our reading here. Something more technology-related that I learned in that reading was that many sex toys sold to women used a dangerous material called “jelly plastics” which contain toxic phthalates. While these materials are still used today, many feminist sex shops have banned them, and there was even the creation of a Coalition Against Toxic Toys (CATT) in Minneapolis that reflects the pushbacks against certain technologies that we’ve learned about in this class. - Noah Rutkowski I am actually in a Perspectives in Sexuality class this semester so this chapter was especially interesting for me to read, and I’d like to add some supplemental information I learned in that class here (I brought this reading up in that class for discussion, too). One of my readings for that class this week was about the evolution of feminist sex shops that first came about in the 1970s, which is quite relevant to our reading here. Something more technology-related that I learned in that reading was that many sex toys sold to women used a dangerous material called “jelly plastics” which contain toxic phthalates. While these materials are still used today, many feminist sex shops have banned them, and there was even the creation of a Coalition Against Toxic Toys (CATT) in Minneapolis that reflects the pushbacks against certain technologies that we’ve learned about in this class. - Noah Rutkowski
  
 I love the idea that these kinds of things implied it wasn't really sexual when it wasn't penetration, when now we know it's often the opposite that's true. The messaging and way that it is advertised is very specific as a way of hiding the true sexual/pleasuring nature, which means that it can bypass societal standards. --- Oliver M I love the idea that these kinds of things implied it wasn't really sexual when it wasn't penetration, when now we know it's often the opposite that's true. The messaging and way that it is advertised is very specific as a way of hiding the true sexual/pleasuring nature, which means that it can bypass societal standards. --- Oliver M
 +
 +This chapter shows how everyday household tools, especially those used by women, are often overlooked as important technologies. It reminds us that social attitudes and gender roles shape what we view as real technological progress. ---Caitlyn Edwards
 +
 +Maines’ discussion of “socially camouflaged technologies” highlights how gender norms shaped what counted as “legitimate” innovation. I was struck by how the vibrator’s medical framing allowed it to exist publicly while concealing its sexual function a reminder that technology doesn’t just evolve through invention, but through the cultural boundaries that decide what’s acceptable. It’s also revealing that early technological records omitted vibrators entirely, showing how historical silences can hide both women’s experiences and entire categories of technological progress. - Todd Holman
  
 ===== Document A -- Taylor =====  ===== Document A -- Taylor ===== 
  
 This document went through the mechanical aspects of a seat design and 'rubbers' and how it worked to effectively pleasure a patient. This idea that self-pleasure is a medical problem that has to be cured like every other medical problem is particularly interesting. Especially when sex for much of human existence particularly for women follows that "close your eyes and think of England" the notion that pleasure did not really matter but only the producing of children or just the manly pleasure aspect did. ---James C This document went through the mechanical aspects of a seat design and 'rubbers' and how it worked to effectively pleasure a patient. This idea that self-pleasure is a medical problem that has to be cured like every other medical problem is particularly interesting. Especially when sex for much of human existence particularly for women follows that "close your eyes and think of England" the notion that pleasure did not really matter but only the producing of children or just the manly pleasure aspect did. ---James C
 +
 +Document A prefers a clinical approach as with the previous one concerning socially camoflauged technologies. Due to a large population of christians in the country it was of utmost importance to ensure that faith was considered, specifically in regards to chastity and the taboos of sexual gratuity. By shifting the reader's impression from that of a sexual proliferation, the document subtly indicates that there is something okay about this specific invention. - Kaden Crim
  
 This is an interesting document that can be used to reinforce Maines’s argument, as this machine is advertised for medical purposes, i.e. it is socially camouflaged. - Nikolai Kotkov  This is an interesting document that can be used to reinforce Maines’s argument, as this machine is advertised for medical purposes, i.e. it is socially camouflaged. - Nikolai Kotkov 
Line 46: Line 57:
  
 Interesting that "releasing pleasure" was a advertised as a medical problem. There's something interesting about how now the same thing is beginning to happen with mental health and how toys are now advertised by releasing pressure and anxiety and stuff. -- Oliver M Interesting that "releasing pleasure" was a advertised as a medical problem. There's something interesting about how now the same thing is beginning to happen with mental health and how toys are now advertised by releasing pressure and anxiety and stuff. -- Oliver M
 +
 +This document was an interesting look at an antecedent to modern vibrators. George H. Taylor’s design seemed incredibly complicated and I’d imagine it would be quite large, which is interesting in comparison to modern vibrators that are now incredibly compact. - Noah Rutkowski
 +
 +his document highlights how medical discourse provided a socially acceptable framework for technologies that were, in reality, about pleasure. The emphasis on “patients” and “treatment” turns what might otherwise seem immoral into something therapeutic, reflecting a broader cultural tension between faith, science, and sexuality. What I find most striking is how the language of cure disguised desire suggesting that pleasure itself was a condition to be managed rather than an experience to be understood. It’s a vivid example of how technology both mirrors and manipulates social values. - Todd Holman
  
 ===== Document B -- Snow =====  ===== Document B -- Snow ===== 
Line 52: Line 67:
  
 Document B goes into vibration and use of therapy. It can help with disorders or other treatments and is described as a therapy and a way to keep calm and pleasure. - Will C  Document B goes into vibration and use of therapy. It can help with disorders or other treatments and is described as a therapy and a way to keep calm and pleasure. - Will C 
 +
 +Document B discusses the usage of sexual aides and how they can benefit a customer as a source of therapy. While partly true, it is largely a play on words and an interpretation of what can otherwise be marked as sexual satisfaction. - Kaden Crim
  
 In this document we’re again seeing the link to medical practices through the marketing/development of the vibrator. This document is listing things that can be treated using the product. - Grayson Donohoe In this document we’re again seeing the link to medical practices through the marketing/development of the vibrator. This document is listing things that can be treated using the product. - Grayson Donohoe
Line 59: Line 76:
 This document discusses different medical conditions that would be cured by the vibrator. I found it interesting that although the topic is inherently sexual, the language of the document is strictly medical, and doesn't illude to anything that would be deemed as "inappropriate". It is marketed as a way to keep calm and relieve pain.  This document discusses different medical conditions that would be cured by the vibrator. I found it interesting that although the topic is inherently sexual, the language of the document is strictly medical, and doesn't illude to anything that would be deemed as "inappropriate". It is marketed as a way to keep calm and relieve pain. 
 - Hannah Holstrom  - Hannah Holstrom 
 +
 +The use of a vibrator to "cure" basically any female sexual health and menstrual condition really reminded me of how modern doctors seem to prescribe birth control in the same way as some magical cure-all for any complaint a woman has. - Noah Rutkowski
 ===== Document C -- Eberhart =====  ===== Document C -- Eberhart ===== 
  
Line 66: Line 85:
  
 Crazy that in this time orgasms were seen as the cure all to all of these. Why hysteria? Why in a time that sex is so taboo that *this* is being advertised? Very interesting. -- Oliver M Crazy that in this time orgasms were seen as the cure all to all of these. Why hysteria? Why in a time that sex is so taboo that *this* is being advertised? Very interesting. -- Oliver M
 +
 +Document C continues as an attempt to justify the introduction of sexual aides into the market. Having struck a cord in earlier examples by describing such inventions as medically practical, Eberhart continues in the same regard. THis time, however, the key work 'therapy' is used, a gray term that draws close and closer to the outward promiscuity of vibrators. - Kaden Crim
 +
 +Similar to the last document, this one lists several medical conditions that can be treated with a vibrator. However, this document also includes the specific “techniques” for each condition, which vary in speed, pressure, etcetera. It was kind of wild to me to read that this doctor had done this process enough times for enough different conditions to feel knowledgeable enough on the topic to write this sort of guide. I’d be interested to know if other doctors had similar “relief” results or if they disagreed with Eberhart’s techniques. - Noah Rutkowski
 +
 +What stands out to me in this document is how the medical language works to legitimize what we would now clearly recognize as a sexual technology. By framing vibrator use as “therapy,” Eberhart and others blurred the line between treatment and pleasure, using the authority of medicine to normalize practices that would have otherwise been socially condemned. It’s fascinating—and unsettling to see how professional discourse could both conceal and enable discussions of sexuality under the guise of scientific progress. - Todd Holman
 ===== Document D -- Covey =====  ===== Document D -- Covey ===== 
  
Line 78: Line 103:
  
 This document focuses on the adaptability and “inventive genius” of the Siebert-Welch apparatus. It’s described as a “condensed mechanism” that physicians could use for treatment that was both convenient and discrete. I like that this gave physicians a way to professionally provide medical care to what probably was a fairly common, and I would venture to say awkward, practice. - Izabella Martinez  This document focuses on the adaptability and “inventive genius” of the Siebert-Welch apparatus. It’s described as a “condensed mechanism” that physicians could use for treatment that was both convenient and discrete. I like that this gave physicians a way to professionally provide medical care to what probably was a fairly common, and I would venture to say awkward, practice. - Izabella Martinez 
 +
 +This document continues to evolve the concept of vibrating apparati as a clinical resource. Concerns from sources arise here such as physicians and therapists who must now work in a more competitive market with a decreased need for intensive human resource, a tale as old as time. - Kaden Crim
  
week_12_questions_comments-325_25.1763040575.txt.gz · Last modified: by 76.78.172.133