Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- 471g4:questions:471g4--week_4_day_2 [2021/09/16 00:57] – lclark7
+++ 471g4:questions:471g4--week_4_day_2 [2021/09/16 13:15] (current) – 98.118.240.108
@@ Line 18: / Line 18: @@
 Submitted by Lyndsey Clark. I pledge...
+. Do you think, if Galt hadn't committed suicide, that the asylum would have kept a integrated staff, even when the Union occupied the area?
+. Do you think Galt's omission from obituaries from the AMSAII has more to do with the war or their less than favorable feelings about him?
+Submitted by Audrey Schroeder. I pledge...
+.What kind of complications came along with allowing other members of the community to recommend institutionalization for an individual that is not apart of their family? How does this complicate the family-physician relationship we saw in asylums like Kirkbride’s?
+.American superintendents only had to adhere to state laws which varied while Britain had a single Lunacy Commission. Do you think a system like the Lunacy Commission would have mitigated some of the discrepancies amongst physicians that negatively affected the patients?
+Submitted by Jack Kurz. I pledge...
+Question 1. Did the civil war cause opinions of “insane” African American patients to worsen or were these opinions already settled?
+Question 2: With the rise in the belief that black people were less susceptible to “insanity” how would this change how psychologists treated or diagnosed insanity in African American patients?
+Submitted by Griffin Nameroff
+,) Saint Elizabeth was regarded as the “National Asylum” and was the epicenter of research and education on mental health. Do to this fact I must ask was their patients that were transferred to this hospital from other institutions across the United States, or was it purely based on the population of Washington D.C
+.) I really don’t understand the 19th century argument that minorities were immune to mental illness due to “Non-stressful agrian” lives, when insanity was prominent in white that were farmers before and after the civil war? That along side the concept of “Cultural-Stasis” just honestly confuses me, like what does that mean?
+- Submitted by Parker Siebenschuh
+.) In Summer's reading, there is a discussion of the "black psyche", and how it is described as "alien" and "fundamentally abnormal". What do you think made the black psyche "abnormal" and "alien"? Do you think the racist atmosphere of the asylum had an impact on or any form of correlation with it?
+.) Also in Summer's reading, there is the notion in which freedom was the main cause of insanity in African Americans. Is there any evidence which can debunk this?
+Submitted by Erica Banks. I pledge....
+) Since environment was believed to influence one’s mental health, why does it appear so difficult for the physicians to assume that the increase in African American asylum patients was due to the fact that their living environments were worse than that of white patients? While they do seem to make that connection, it is very loose and does not mention the fact that African American living environments were worse often due to society and not their own ambitions or choice. (Summers)
+) Were African American patients stigmatized along with white and other mentally patients or were they stigmatized within their category? (Summers)
+Submitted by Mallory Karnei. I pledge…
+. Throughout the Gonaver reading, it is clear that the mental health is intersectional, but in the middle of that is race. Dr. Francis Stribing stated that the "Colored Insane [are] a class now rapidly increasing," while arguing for a new and separate facility for black patients in Virginia (177). Summers also noted that by racializing the disease, you racialize the sufferer. Why is this still sometimes the narrative that is being believed by doctors (in the mental health field or otherwise)?
+. Going along with the last question, there was an argument brought forward that the mental health of black men and women was suffering because of the affects of freedom on them after slavery. Why do you think this was thought?
+I pledge… Carson Berrier