Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- 329:question:329--week_9_questions_comments-2026 [2026/11/01 03:06] – [How does this movie work as a secondary source about the past? What does the movie get right about history?] 96.255.218.104
+++ 329:question:329--week_9_questions_comments-2026 [2026/11/01 16:25] (current) – [The "So What" Question -- Why should we care about the movie and its version of history?] 174.219.244.194
@@ Line 54: / Line 54: @@
 -Ellie Irwin
+My Darling Clementine is a post-World War II film and in many ways, it is a prism through which historians can view the time in which it was made. Wyatt Earp’s character, for example, can be seen as an allegory of America’s role in World War II - a person who gains in strength and character throughout the film, eventually taking down a gang of bad guys with his two allies. At the end of the movie, after bringing justice to Tombstone, Earp leaves, but promises to come back, reflecting the question for many Americans and the wider world of whether the United States would stick around in its new post-war global role or retrench into isolationism. The film works as a primary source about the time in which it was made because it reflects many of the sentiments and cultural paradigms of the post-war period.  There is good versus evil, justice over outlaws, and justice over impunity.  In the end, the Clanton family did not succeed in getting away with killing Wyatt Earp’s brother or bullying their way around the town. At the same time, there was less gun-slinging than in most western films, possibly an acknowledgement of the general public desire for peace and stability. -Charles Salcedo
+I think My Darling Clementine works as a primary source because it shows how people in the 1940s viewed and remembered the American West. Even though the movie takes place in the 1880s, it reflects the values and ideas of the time it was made in 1946. The movie makes the West seem like a place where good people bring law and order to a world full of violence and chaos. So, I think it tells us more about how people wanted to remember the Old West than what had actually happened at the times. —Cait Edwards.
 ======The "So What" Question -- Why should we care about the movie and its version of history?======
@@ Line 71: / Line 73: @@
 My Darling Clementine is one iteration of Wyatt Earp's “story” among many others. This film does not address a major event in American history, and does not have the same historical rewriting effect other films we’ve watched do. This film was directed by one of the most famous American movie creators of all time, which does lend it more popularity than others. I do not believe that this single film matters much, but this film existing alongside the greater Western genre does matter. Many people get their first impressions about American expansion westward from media depicting stories like this film does. While school does teach about manifest destiny and all that, the day to day life of people is lost. This is filled in by Western media. Stereotypes of Native Americans and other groups that American citizens came into contact with are rampant among this genre, and shape public attitudes towards these groups where they continue to reside today. -Katie D.
+I think we should care about My Darling Clementine because movies like this can change how people picture historical figures and events. The movie makes Wyatt Earp look like this ‘perfect hero’ who came into town to bring ‘peace and justice’, even though in reality he was not exactly like that. I think Hollywood wanted its audiences to have someone to root for, so they turned the real people and events into a more entertaining Western story. Even if the movie isn’t completely historically accurate, it is still important because it shows how Hollywood helped create the American legend of the Wild West. —Cait Edwards .
 Like most of John Ford’s filmography, My Darling Clementine perpetuates the fantastical ideal of the Western Frontier, adding to America's long list of mythology: Billy the Kid, Butch Cassidy, Buffalo Bill, and, naturally, Wyatt Earp. As such, America’s fanaticism regarding the Wild West has not, and will never be, a passing fancy, as seen in “Theodore Roosevelt Describes the Cowboy-Land, 1893,” where Roosevelt says, “most of the men with whom I was intimately thrown during my life on the frontier and in the wilderness were good fellows, hard-working, brave, resolute, and truthful.” However, this description ignores—much like the film itself does, given it was created in 1946—a majority of the westward expansion's more delicate intricacies, such as the prosecution of Native Americans and conflicts between urban and rural centers of commerce. Regardless, My Darling Clementine is one of the foundational pillars of the Western genre and, much like the Shootout at O.K. Corral, will remain in America's memory as the keystone of the idealized Wild West. - Bailee E.